Free Local Delivery On Orders over $29

New Store Hours! Effective November 2, 2026: Monday–Saturday 10:00 AM–8:00 PM; Sunday 10:00 AM–6:00 PM

Cat toys

Showing 17-32 of 41


  • Canophera silvervine catnip ball cat toy on retail card

    CANOPHERA

    Canophera Silvervine Catnip Ball Cat Toy

    $7.99
    A little ball of sticks. A whole lot of feline excitement! 🐱🐾 Get ready to roll with the Canophera Silvervine Catnip Ball, a naturally enticing toy designed to bring out your kitty’s wild side! This clever little creation features a cage-like ball made from natural silvervine sticks, with a catnip-filled...

    $7.99
    View details
  • Colorful plush pom cat toy balls, three multi-pom balls with soft fuzzy texture. Multicolor plush pom cat toy ball with bell inside, held by a gray cat.

    SMOKEYS STASH

    Smokey's Stash Cat Toy Plush Pom Cat Balls with Bells Inside

    $6.99
    Our Plush cat ball toys with bells are built to last and provide hours of exercise for your cats and kittens! Shake, Rattle and Roll! • Perfectly safe for all cats and kittens! Made from eco friendly material! • Perfect for indoor cats! Use some of our catnip spray for...

    $6.99
    View details
  • Pink LED cat pointer with metal key ring and clip Blue LED cat pointer with metal key ring and clip

    COASTAL

    Coastal Turbo Cat LED Pointer

    $6.99
    Gentle LED light is safe for cats sensitive eyes. Fun animal projection engages natural hunting instincts. Encourages active play and exercise. Increases mental stimulation. Three different LED light projections to choose from.

    $6.99
    View details
  • Cat grass garden balls starter set with bright green grass in colorful pots and boxes

    Paws on Chicon

    Tailswag Cat Grass Garden Balls

    $11.99
    Our Cat Grass Kits include everything you need to easily grow healthy Cat Grass. Cat owners will enjoy growing these organic cat grass gardens. Small, colorful self-watering planters are 3" round. They contain Organic soil and our own organic blend of 3 types of grasses. Rye, barley, and oat. The...

    $11.99
    View details
  • FRINGE TOYBOX CAT TUNA RIGHT MEOW 2PC

    FRINGE

    PetShop Tuna Right Meow Cat Toy 2PC

    $11.99
    Time to seas the day! Our “Tuna Right Meow” 2 piece plush toy set is purrfect for the playful kitty. Made with super soft plush, crazy crinkle paper, and North American grown catnip, these toys were designed with interactive play in mind. Great for pounce, bat, chase, and play, this...

    $11.99
    View details
  • FRINGE TOYBOX CAT CATCH ME IF YOU CAN 3PC

    FRINGE

    PetShop Catch Me If You Can Canvas Mini Cat Toy 3PC

    $13.99
    This “Catch Me If You Can” 3 piece mini toy set is purrfect for the quick kitty. Made with durable cotton canvas, North American grown catnip, crazy crinkle paper, and dangling rope, these toys were designed with interactive play in mind and a look that complements modern home décor. Whether...

    $13.99
    View details
  • Three faux fur cat bat arounds in orange, green, and teal with fuzzy texture Faux fur cat bat arounds set in sealed packs, with orange, red, black, and green

    GO CAT FEATHER TOYS Inc.

    GO CAT Faux Fur Bat Arounds 3 PK

    $4.99
    Go Cat Feather Toys’ Bat Arounds are a great cat toy that provides hours of fun for cats and their owners. Bat Arounds are sure to provide cats with hours of entertainment.

    $4.99
    View details
  • Green plush cat toy with embroidered face, spikes, and curled tail, front view Green plush cat toy with spiky edges, stitched smile and nose, and curled tail

    SNUGAROOZ

    Kitty Chloe

    $5.99
    Give your kitty a new best friend with the Snugarooz Kitty Chloe! This adorable plush cat toy is designed to provide endless fun with its crinkly texture and catnip-filled core, keeping your feline entertained and engaged. Crafted from eco-friendly, non-toxic materials, Kitty Chloe is soft, safe, and purr-fect for batting, wrestling, and snuggling. The irresistible catnip...

    $5.99
    View details
  • Yellow cat-shaped plush stuffed toy with brown face and embroidered whiskers Cat-shaped yellow plush toy with brown spots, rounded body, and embroidered smile

    SNUGAROOZ

    Tacocat

    $9.99
    Discover the delightful mystery of #tacocat! A whimsical blend of two favorites - is it a taco, or is it a cat? Maybe it's both! Unveil the fun and excitement with this unique toy, featuring an irresistible crinkle and an engaging squeaker. Plus, it's crafted with a commitment to sustainability,...

    $9.99
    View details
  • Two braided rope cat toys with rainbow felt tail tabs Braided rope cat toy with rainbow felt tail strip

    CAT DANCER

    Cat Dancer Ringtail Chaser 2 Pack

    $4.99
    A piece of the special lure from Cat Dancer® and a brightly colored piece of fleece combine in a cat’s imagination to create irresistible play, chase and fun. Package of 2.

    $4.99
    View details
  • CatDancer Original interactive cat toy in retail package with illustrated dog Interactive cat toy with long cord and braided mouse with catnip scent

    CAT DANCER

    Cat Dancer Interactive Cat Toy

    $3.99
    Cat Dancer is the original interactive cat toy. Spring steel wire and rolled cardboard create an irresistible lure for cats and great fun for cat lovers. Home-tested by over 8 million cats.

    $3.99
    View details
  • Cat Dancer Deluxe cat teaser toy with paw-shaped wand and braided teaser strips

    CAT DANCER

    Cat Dancer Deluxe Cat Teaser Toy

    $8.99
    The Cat Dancer Deluxe is our Original Cat Dancer handheld toy packaged with a plastic paw that is to be attached to a wall to hold the toy for cats to play alone.  It is attached to the wall using Command Strips which we include in the package.  It takes...

    $8.99
    View details
  • Plush kitten dolls, green and orange outfits with bowtie and paw patches

    FAT CAT

    Fat Cat Classic Kitten Little

    $5.99
    FAT CAT® Kitten Little® toys will throw even the most Potato-Like (as in lumpy couch potato) cats into a sweet frenzy of the highest level. We've made them small for supreme airborne possibilities. Filled with our exclusive Zoom Around the Room® high-test organic catnip.

    $5.99
    View details
  • Blue plush shark cat toy with ribbon teaser and fluffy kicker tail Blue plush shark cat toy kicker ring with dangling ribbon and fluffy tail

    MAD CAT

    Mad Cat Shark Twisty Kicker with Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

    $10.99
    The Mad Cat® Shark Twisty Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy will be a cat's new best friend! This soft and silly toy is filled with a custom blend of tempting catnip and silvervine for twice the cat attractants, plus a fun crinkle for enticing sound. Silvervine is an all-natural...

    $10.99
    View details
  • Colorful plush springy worm cat toys with loop tails and cartoon faces

    FAT CAT

    Fat Cat Classic Springy Worms 2pk

    $5.99
    FAT CAT® Spring Technology for Cat Psychology! Cats will bounce in no time with these Springy Worms. These catnip toys are especially made with cat psychology in mind. Contains our famous Zoom Around the Room!® high-test organic catnip. Two toys per pack. Ships in random fun assorted colors.

    $5.99
    View details
  • Cat whisker chaser 2-pack toy set with multicolor feather-stick chasers (package) Multicolor plush strip cat toy with bundled feather sticks

    CAT DANCER

    Cat Dancer Whisker Chaser 2PK

    $4.99
    They’re fun to carry and fetch, they look a bit like a spider and your cat will go crazy for these tough little toys. Package of 2. A piece of the special lure from Cat Dancer and a brightly colored piece of fleece combine in a cat’s imagination to create...

    $4.99
    View details